Study from HBS Shows Isolated Stands of Red Spruce Persist . . . For Now
In two secluded Appalachian basins, a northern forest persists under southern skies. But its future remains uncertain.
There are places in the mountains where the seasons seem to arrive by another calendar.
Cold gathers there long after it has loosened its grip on the surrounding slopes. Water seeps quietly through the earth. Beneath the dark, leathery leaves of rhododendron, the air holds a dampness that belongs, somehow, to a place farther north.
In the Nantahala National Forest, two such places have kept something remarkable.
Their names are Alarka Laurel and Rich Mountain. Neither is especially large, nor would either announce itself as extraordinary to someone passing through the surrounding forest. Yet within these sheltered basins grow two of the southernmost populations of red spruce in North America, remnants of a colder Appalachian world.
Red spruce is a tree more commonly associated with the forests of New England and southeastern Canada, with long winters, persistent fog, and soils that seldom fully dry. Here, near the southern edge of its range, it generally seeks the higher elevations, where the air retains something of its northern character.
But the mountains are seldom so simple.
At Alarka Laurel, spruce grows at roughly 1,220 meters (4,000 feet), well below its usual southern elevation. Rich Mountain lies higher, near 1,460 meters (4,800 feet). In both places, the contours of the land create their own peculiar weather. Cold air slips down from the ridges after nightfall and gathers in the hollows, while springs and seeps keep the ground moist.
The result is a small geography of cold, a landscape in which the climate of another age has found a place to linger.
Two hidden basins. One northern tree, far from its core range.
The long retreat
It is tempting to think of these trees as wanderers, having somehow strayed beyond the boundaries of their natural world.
But the spruce did not necessarily travel here. In a sense, the world traveled away from them.
Thousands of years ago, when glacial climates held much of eastern North America in their influence, red spruce occupied a broader swath of the Appalachian landscape. As the climate warmed, suitable conditions withdrew northward and upslope. Forests changed their composition. Trees that had once shared the mountains began to occupy increasingly separate worlds.
Some spruce populations persisted where the land could shelter them from the changes taking place beyond.
What remains at Alarka Laurel and Rich Mountain is not a preserved fragment of an ancient forest, unchanged through millennia. These are living communities, shaped by disturbance, competition, death, and renewal. Their trees have come and gone through countless generations. What has endured is something less visible: a set of conditions that continues to make life possible for a species otherwise nearing the limits of its southern range.
Even here, the past has not been especially gentle.
At Rich Mountain, old stumps speak to a period of timber harvest during the early twentieth century. At Alarka Laurel, an insect outbreak in the early 2000s took a toll on the larger spruce. The forests have weathered these disturbances differently, their present forms bearing the marks of events that happened decades apart.
Their survival, then, is not the absence of change.
It is what has happened in spite of it.
Alarka Laurel
- Elevation
- about 1,220 m (4,000 ft)
- Basin
- about 16 ha (40 acres)
- Nearest spruce
- 18.5 km (11.5 mi) away, in the Plott Balsams
- Surveyed
- 2007 and 2022
No sign the basin was ever logged. The oldest spruce cored in the 2007 survey dated to 1855. In the early 2000s, southern pine beetles struck the stand, and many of its big spruce died.
Rich Mountain
- Elevation
- about 1,460 m (4,790 ft)
- Basin
- about 4 ha (10 acres)
- Nearest spruce
- 5.6 km (3.5 mi) away, at Rough Butt and Gauge Bald in the Great Balsams
- Surveyed
- 2023
Owned for timber by the Mead Paper Company and likely logged from the 1920s to the 1940s; stumps still ring the bog. Public land since 1980–81.
Spruce bogs are small, wet and easily damaged, and some of the seedlings counted here were shorter than your thumb. The best way to visit these two is from this page.
Learning to read a forest
In 2022 and 2023, students from the University of North Carolina’s Institute for the Environment, working through Highlands Biological Station with Associate Director Jason Love and Highlands Field Site Director Dr. Rada Petric, entered these basins with a deceptively simple question.
How were the spruce doing?
The answer required more than looking toward the canopy.
A forest can appear unchanged from a distance, its familiar crowns still standing against the sky, while the composition of its understory is quietly shifting. Large trees tell us something about the conditions of decades past. To understand what might come next, we must also look beneath them.
The students measured the forests in careful sections, recording trees of different sizes, their health, and the abundance of young growth. At Alarka Laurel, they returned to the work of an earlier survey conducted in 2007 by Western Carolina University’s Dr. Beverly Collins and her team.
Five lines across a basin
Three sizes of tree
Try it: score these spruce
Every spruce, from the tallest to the smallest seedling, was given a health score from 0 to 3.
- 3Good
- 2Fair
- 1Poor
- 0Dead
What score would you give it?
What score would you give it?
What score would you give it?
What score would you give it?
Fifteen years separated the two inventories.
For us, that is a considerable span of time. For a red spruce, it may be little more than a chapter.
And yet, in those fifteen years, something important had changed.
Fifteen years later, students went back to count again.
One hectare, three counts
A single hectare of spruce bog (about 2.5 acres), filled in with the average number of trees per hectare from each survey. Choose a count to watch the forest change.
- Overstory red spruce69
- Other overstory trees215
- Red spruce saplings72
- Red spruce seedlings429
At Alarka Laurel, the combined cross-sectional area of living red spruce trunks—a measure ecologists call basal area—had declined by nearly half. Some of the largest trees were gone. Other species, including red maple, had gained ground.
Seen only through the lives of the largest trees, the forest might have appeared to be retreating.
But the ground beneath them suggested a more complicated story.
The density of young spruce saplings had increased roughly fivefold. Seedlings, once recorded in about a third of the surveyed plots, were now present in nearly two-thirds.
At Rich Mountain, the pattern was different. Its forest retained more substantial mature spruce, including large old trees, but supported fewer young spruce than Alarka Laurel.
In both basins, however, the researchers found abundant regeneration. Seedlings and saplings accounted for between approximately half and six-sevenths of the red spruce counted, and the youngest trees were generally the healthiest.
The forest was not merely surviving as a collection of old trees.
It was still making new ones.
How these stands compare
What the light allows
The beginnings of a forest are easy to overlook.
A spruce seedling may be scarcely larger than a few fallen leaves, its delicate needles close to the damp earth. It occupies a world measured not in acres or elevations but in inches of light, the reach of nearby roots, and the brief opening of a canopy overhead.
For a young spruce, shade can offer both shelter and constraint.
The dense understory of rosebay rhododendron and mountain laurel helps define these mountain bogs, but it can also intercept much of the light that would otherwise reach the forest floor. Red maple, increasingly common in parts of the eastern forest, adds another layer of competition.
A fallen tree changes that arrangement.
Where its crown once stood, daylight reaches into the understory. The change may be modest, a patch of brightness moving across the ground, but for a sapling that has spent years beneath the canopy, it can make the difference between remaining small and beginning to grow.
A young spruce waits in the shade of a red maple.
The researchers found young spruce flourishing particularly in these openings. Their findings suggest that carefully increasing light in selected areas—by reducing dense shrub cover or selectively removing competing red maple—might help the next generation develop.
Such work would require a measured hand, and continued observation to understand its consequences.
There is something instructive in the modesty of that recommendation.
The future of these forests may depend less on dramatic intervention than on understanding the particular conditions under which they have managed to persist.
A little light. Enough moisture. A place where the night still gathers cold.
And time.
The uncertain mercy of a refuge
When the hardwoods go bare, the spruce stands out.
What remains
Winter lends a certain clarity to these mountains.
The hardwoods shed their leaves, exposing the intricate architecture of their branches. The ridgelines grow spare. Against that pale, open woodland, the spruce retain their dark green, a color belonging to no particular season.
It is easy to look at such trees and think of endurance as a matter of age: the breadth of a trunk, the height of a crown, the number of winters held within the wood.
But at Alarka Laurel and Rich Mountain, endurance may be better understood as a continuing exchange between the old forest and the new.
The great trees have not all survived. The climate that once favored them has not remained unchanged. The forests themselves are neither fixed nor assured.
And still, the young spruce grow.
For now, the mountains continue to gather cold in these sheltered places. Water moves beneath the evergreen leaves. A little light reaches the understory where an older tree has fallen.
The rest belongs to seasons we have not yet seen.